Last updated: July 2026
Quick Summary: RAF (Responsible Animal Fiber) is the overarching certification framework, while RWS (Responsible Wool Standard) is one of the specific standards within that framework. Think of RAF as the umbrella and RWS, RMS, and RAS as the individual standards underneath it. After the farm level, all certification operates under the RAF umbrella (RAF-102-V2.1 B1.1).
RAF vs RWS: Key Differences
| Dimension | RAF (Responsible Animal Fiber) | RWS (Responsible Wool Standard) |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Certification framework (umbrella) | Individual product standard |
| Scope | Covers all animal fiber standards (RWS, RMS, RAS) | Sheep wool only |
| Document Reference | RAF-102-V2.1 (Certification Procedures) | RAF-101a-V2.2 (Standard) |
| Covers | Certification procedures, auditor qualifications, accreditation criteria | Animal welfare, land management, social welfare, chain of custody for wool |
| Supply Chain | Processors certified under the RAF umbrella (B1.1) | Farm to final product for wool specific |
| Owner | Textile Exchange | Textile Exchange |
| Latest Version | V2.1 (July 2021) | V2.2 (October 2021) |
| Farm Audit Scope | Defines procedures but does not set farm criteria | Sections C (AW), D (LM), E (SW) — full farm criteria |
| Processor Audit Scope | All supply chain sites under RAF umbrella | Section G — chain of custody (CCS-based) |
Understanding the Relationship
RAF (Responsible Animal Fiber)
Framework — Certification Procedures (RAF-102-V2.1)
├─ RWS (Responsible Wool Standard) — RAF-101a-V2.2
├─ RMS (Responsible Mohair Standard) — RAF-101b-V1.2
└─ RAS (Responsible Alpaca Standard) — RAF-101c-V1.0
The key distinction is that RAF is a procedural framework, while RWS is a content standard. The RAF Certification Procedures (RAF-102-V2.1) define how certification bodies, auditors, and accreditation bodies operate across all animal fiber standards. The RWS standard (RAF-101a-V2.2) defines the specific criteria that farms and supply chain sites must meet for wool certification.
As stated in the RWS standard (B1.1): "After the farm level, certification is under the umbrella of Responsible Animal Fiber, which includes both the Responsible Wool Standard and the Responsible Mohair Standard [and the Responsible Alpaca Standard]." This means that once raw fiber leaves the farm, its certification status is managed under the broader RAF framework.
RAF vs RWS: Detailed Comparison by Category
Purpose and Function
RAF defines the certification procedures — how audits are conducted, how auditors are qualified, how certification decisions are made (RAF-102-V2.1 D1-D4). RWS defines the standard requirements — what farms must do regarding animal nutrition, living environment, land management, and social welfare (RWS V2.2 Sections C, D, E).
Document Hierarchy
The RAF Certification Procedures (RAF-102-V2.1) reference the individual standards (RAF-101a for RWS, RAF-101b for RMS, RAF-101c for RAS) as key documents for conducting RAF certification (B2.2). The RWS standard in turn references CCS-101 for chain-of-custody requirements and ASR-101 for accreditation procedures. This creates a nested document hierarchy where:
- RAF-102 (Certification Procedures) → How to certify
- RAF-101a/b/c (Standards) → What to certify against
- CCS-101 (Chain of Custody) → How to track material
- ASR-101 (Accreditation Procedures) → How to accredit CBs
Auditor Qualifications
The RAF Certification Procedures define auditor qualifications that go beyond general Textile Exchange requirements (RAF-102-V2.1 D1.1.1). RAF auditors must have training and experience with mammalian livestock and pasture-based agriculture. For RWS, this specifically means experience with sheep. This species-specific requirement is set at the RAF (framework) level, not the RWS (standard) level.
Farm Certification Types
The RWS standard defines three certification types for farms: Individual Farm Certification (B3.5), Farm Group Certification (B3.6), and Communal Farmer Group Certification (B3.7). The RAF Certification Procedures provide the operational details for auditing each type, including audit duration guidelines (D2.6), sampling methodologies for farm groups (D3.2), and certification duration rules (D4).
Chain of Custody
For supply chain sites beyond the farm (processors, manufacturers, traders), both RAF and RWS point to the same CCS-based chain-of-custody system. The RWS standard specifies that Section G (Chain of Custody) applies to all supply chain sites (B5.1). The RAF Certification Procedures provide the audit framework for verifying CCS compliance across all RAF standards.
When to Choose RAF vs RWS
| Scenario | Recommendation | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Wool farm seeking certification | RWS certification | Farm-level criteria are defined in the RWS standard (Sections C, D, E) |
| Wool processor/trader | RWS (under RAF umbrella) | Processors are certified under the RAF umbrella; their scope is RWS material |
| Multi-species farm (sheep + goats) | RWS + RMS (two certificates) | A farm may hold one Individual Farm Certification per RAF standard (B3.7) |
| Understanding certification requirements | Read RWS standard + RAF procedures | RWS defines what to do; RAF defines how certification works |
| Becoming a certification body | RAF procedures + ASR-101 | CBs must follow RAF Certification Procedures and ASR-101 |
RWS vs RMS vs RAS Within the RAF Framework
For completeness, it is helpful to understand how all three standards within the RAF framework relate to each other:
| Standard | Document | Fiber | Version | Effective |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| RWS | RAF-101a | Sheep Wool | V2.2 | Oct 2021 (audits after Jan 2022) |
| RMS | RAF-101b | Mohair (Angora Goats) | V1.2 | See standard |
| RAS | RAF-101c | Alpaca Fiber | V1.0 | See standard |
All three standards share the same RAF Certification Procedures (RAF-102-V2.1) and the same CCS-based chain-of-custody system. The differences are in the species-specific animal welfare requirements and the fiber types they cover.
FAQ: RAF vs RWS
Q: Is RAF the same as RWS?
A: No. RAF (Responsible Animal Fiber) is the overarching certification framework, while RWS (Responsible Wool Standard) is one of three standards within that framework. RWS covers sheep wool; RMScovers mohair; RAS covers alpaca fiber. All share the same RAF certification procedures.
Q: Can I get RAF certified without RWS?
A: You would certify to one of the specific standards (RWS, RMS, or RAS) rather than to "RAF" directly. The RAF framework provides the certification procedures, but the actual certification is to the relevant standard for your fiber type.
Q: Does RAF cover alpaca fiber?
A: Yes. The RAF framework includes the Responsible Alpaca Standard (RAS, RAF-101c-V1.0), which covers alpaca fiber certification. Alpaca farms and processors are certified under the same RAF certification procedures as RWS and RMS.
Q: Which document should I read for wool certification?
A: For wool certification requirements, read the RWS standard (RAF-101a-V2.2). For understanding the certification process, auditor qualifications, and procedural rules, read the RAF Certification Procedures (RAF-102-V2.1). Both are essential for a complete understanding.
Q: Does RAF or RWS set certification fees?
A: Neither sets certification fees. Fees are determined by individual certification bodies based on their own pricing structures, audit duration, and associated costs. Both the RAF procedures and the RWS standard direct users to contact certification bodies for quotations.
Q: How often are RAF and RWS updated?
A: The RWS undergoes revision at least every five years (RWS V2.2, line 16). The RAF Certification Procedures are typically revised alongside the RWS (RAF-102-V2.1, line 48-49). The next revision was tentatively scheduled to begin in 2024 for completion in 2025.
Conclusion
RAF and RWS are not competing certifications — they are complementary layers of the same system. RAF provides the procedural framework for certification, while RWS (along with RMS and RAS) provides the specific requirements for each fiber type. Understanding this relationship is essential for anyone navigating animal fiber certification, whether you are a farmer, processor, brand, or certification body.
When people say "RWS certified," they are referring to certification against the Responsible Wool Standard under the RAF framework. The two terms are often used interchangeably in practice, but knowing the distinction helps in reading the correct documents and understanding how the system works.
Need Help Understanding RAF vs RWS?
Contact our experts for guidance on animal fiber certification.
Get Free ConsultationTRANWIN MANAGEMENT CONSULTING CO.,LTD.
CONTACT: Mr. David Lee
E-MAIL: chaowang@tranwin.net(prefered)
MOBILE:18601633226
TEL: 0086-21-51029391
WECHAT: LISHUNDAO
ADD: No. 655 Yinxiang Road, Nanxiang Town, Jiading District, Shanghai







