SEDEX Audit Report: How to Read and Interpret 2026-TRANWIN CONSULTING
Hotline

GRS认证

Current LocationHome> Certification Factory Audit>SEDEX Factory Audit>SEDEX Audit Report: How to Read and Interpret 2026

SEDEX Audit Report: How to Read and Interpret 2026

Source: 2026-11-18 07:07 by TRANWIN CONSULTING SEDEX Audit Report: How to Read and Interpret 2026 Read: 5

Once your SMETA (Sedex Members' Ethical Trade Audit) is complete, the Affiliated Audit Company (AAC) produces two key documents: the Corrective Action Plan Report (CAPR) and the Full Audit Report. Understanding how to read and interpret these reports is essential for factory managers, compliance teams, and buyers who need to evaluate audit results and manage corrective actions.

This guide explains the structure of SMETA audit reports, the meaning of finding types and criticality levels, how to interpret Management Systems Assessment (MSA) grades, and what each finding requires for closure. All information is based on the SMETA 7.0 methodology.

The Two Key Outputs of a SMETA Audit

Every SMETA audit produces two reports that serve different purposes:

Corrective Action Plan Report (CAPR) — A summary document listing all audit findings, their criticality, and required corrective actions. This is the primary tool for managing follow-up and closure. It includes MSA grades for each pillar.

Full Audit Report — A detailed document providing context and descriptions of each finding, including evidence examined, site observations, worker interview summaries, and photographic evidence. This report gives buyers a complete picture of the site's compliance status.

Both reports are uploaded to the SEDEX platform, where suppliers can share them with multiple buyers.

Understanding Finding Types

SMETA 7.0 recognises four types of findings. Each type communicates a different level of compliance:

Finding Type Definition What It Means for Your Site
Non-Compliance (NC) Site does not meet local or international law Most serious — legal violation. Must be corrected promptly. Higher priority for buyers.
Non-Conformance Site meets local law but not the ETI Base Code Meets legal minimum but not international best practice. Still requires corrective action.
Collaborative Action Required (CAR) Issue requiring multi-stakeholder collaboration Beyond site's direct control. No fixed closure date. Requires buyer-supplier collaboration.
Good Example Practice exceeding both local law and ETI Base Code Positive finding. Demonstrates best practice and can be used as a case study.

Understanding Criticality Levels

Each finding (except Good Examples) is assigned a criticality level that determines the urgency and method of corrective action:

Criticality Definition Designation Closure Requirement
Business Critical Imminent or serious risk to life, or severe human rights impact F (Follow-up) Immediate corrective action; on-site follow-up required
Critical Systemic, deliberate, or severe breach representing danger to workers F (Follow-up) CAPR within 7 working days; on-site follow-up within 30 days
Major Systemic breach that could present danger or violate human rights F (Follow-up) CAPR within 7 working days; on-site follow-up within 30 days
Minor Isolated breach with low risk D (Desktop) Submit evidence within 15 working days; desktop review only

Designation "F" (Follow-up) means the finding requires an on-site visit to verify corrective actions. The site must submit a Corrective Action Plan Report (CAPR) within 7 working days and schedule the follow-up audit within approximately 30 days.

Designation "D" (Desktop) means the finding can be closed through remote verification. The site uploads evidence (photos, certificates, policies) to the SEDEX platform, and the auditor reviews it within 5 working days.

Management Systems Assessment (MSA) Grades

A key feature of SMETA 7.0 is the Management Systems Assessment (MSA), which evaluates the site's management systems for each pillar. The MSA assesses four elements for each compliance area:

  1. Policies and Procedures — Does the site have written policies covering the requirement?
  2. Resources and Responsibilities — Is a manager assigned with authority and accountability?
  3. Communication and Training — Are workers trained and informed about their rights and procedures?
  4. Monitoring — Does the site track and review compliance regularly?

Each element is graded on the following scale:

MSA Grade Meaning Implication
Not Addressed No policy, system, or procedure in place Significant gap — requires immediate development of management systems
Fundamental Improvements Required Basic systems exist but have critical gaps Major improvements needed — systems are not reliable
Some Improvements Recommended Systems are functional but have room for improvement Good foundation — targeted improvements will strengthen compliance
Robust Management System Comprehensive, effective systems in place
Step Action Timeline
1 Review the CAPR and understand each finding Immediately after receiving the report
2 Conduct root cause analysis for each finding Within the CAPR timeline
3 Define corrective actions with responsible persons and target dates 7 working days for F-designated findings
4 Submit CAPR with corrective action plan As per agreed timeline
5 Implement corrective actions By target completion dates
6 Submit evidence (desktop) or schedule follow-up (on-site) Desktop: evidence reviewed within 5 working days
Follow-up: within 6 months of initial audit
7 Auditor updates CAPR status — Closed or Open After verification complete

FAQ: SMETA Audit Reports

Q: How long after the audit do I receive the report?

A: The AAC typically uploads the completed audit report to the SEDEX platform within 5-10 working days after the on-site audit. The timeline may vary depending on the AAC's workload and the complexity of findings.

Q: What is the difference between an open and closed finding?

A: An Open finding means the auditor has not yet received sufficient evidence to confirm that the issue has been resolved. A Closed finding means the auditor has reviewed and accepted the corrective action evidence. Open findings remain active until closed.

Q: Can a buyer reject a SMETA report?

A: Yes. Since SMETA is not a certification with a pass/fail grade, each buyer independently evaluates the report and decides whether the findings are acceptable for their business relationship. A buyer may request a follow-up audit, additional corrective actions, or suspend orders if Business Critical or Critical findings remain unresolved.

Q: What happens during a follow-up audit?

A: A follow-up audit is an on-site visit conducted by the same AAC used for the initial audit. The auditor focuses specifically on the NCs identified in the previous audit. The follow-up includes an opening meeting, site tour, document review, and worker interviews. New issues found during the follow-up are recorded in a new CAPR. The follow-up generally takes place within 6 months of the initial audit.

Q: Can I share my SMETA report with non-SEDEX members?

A: The SMETA report is uploaded to the SEDEX platform and can be shared with any buyer who is a SEDEX member. For non-SEDEX members, you may need to provide the report directly, but this is less common as most major retailers requiring SMETA are SEDEX members.

Q: How long is a SMETA report valid?

A: The SMETA report is generally considered valid for 24 months as a reference document. However, individual buyers may set their own validity periods. High-risk sites are typically expected to audit annually, while medium-risk sites may audit every two years.

Conclusion

Reading and interpreting a SMETA audit report is a skill that improves with practice. The key is to focus on finding types and criticality levels to prioritise corrective actions, understand MSA grades to identify systemic issues, and follow the CAPR process to close findings efficiently.

A well-managed audit report — with findings closed promptly and management systems improving over time — signals to buyers that your site is committed to ethical compliance and continuous improvement.

Need Help Interpreting a SMETA Audit Report?

Our compliance specialists can help you understand audit findings, plan corrective actions, and prepare for follow-up audits. Contact us for expert support.

Get Free Consultation

Tag
Contact Us

TRANWIN MANAGEMENT CONSULTING CO.,LTD.


CONTACT: Mr. David Lee

E-MAIL: chaowang@tranwin.net(prefered)

MOBILE:18601633226

TEL: 0086-21-51029391 

WECHAT: LISHUNDAO

ADD: No. 655 Yinxiang Road, Nanxiang Town, Jiading District, Shanghai


ASIAN OFFICES

Hanoi Office, Vietnam

Ho Chi Minh Office, Vietnam

Cambodia Office

Thailand Office

Malaysia Office

The Leading Factory Audit Consulting Company from China to Asia